Banquo

 

How does Shakespeare present Banquo as a threat to Macbeth?

AO1 (10 marks) – Knowledge & Understanding

(What Shakespeare shows about Banquo as a threat)

Shakespeare presents Banquo as a serious and growing threat to Macbeth because he represents future kingship, moral goodness, and natural authority, all of which undermine Macbeth’s insecure rule.

At the start of the play, Banquo is introduced as Macbeth’s “noble partner”, showing they are close allies. This makes Banquo’s later role as a threat more powerful, because Macbeth is ultimately betrayed by someone he once trusted.

The witches’ prophecy immediately creates danger. They say Banquo will be “Lesser than Macbeth, and greater” and “father to a line of kings.” This means that although Macbeth becomes king first, Banquo’s descendants will eventually rule Scotland. This threatens Macbeth’s ambition because his kingship has no future legacy, unlike Banquo’s.

Macbeth quickly recognises this danger, admitting: “Our fears in Banquo stick deep.” This shows Banquo is not a minor concern but a deep, lasting source of insecurity. Macbeth also describes Banquo as having “royalty of nature,” suggesting Banquo has natural king-like qualities, making Macbeth feel inferior and unsafe on the throne.

Banquo also threatens Macbeth morally and politically because he remains loyal and honest. He says, “keep my allegiance clear,” showing he refuses to act dishonestly or violently. This contrast makes Banquo a reminder of the moral path Macbeth has abandoned.

Banquo also becomes suspicious of Macbeth after Duncan’s murder, saying: “I fear thou play’dst most foully for’t.” This increases Macbeth’s fear because Banquo may expose his crime, threatening both his crown and reputation.

Because of this fear, Macbeth orders Banquo’s murder, showing Banquo has become a political threat. However, Banquo becomes even more powerful after death when his ghost appears at the banquet. Macbeth panics: “Never shake thy gory locks at me!” At this point, Banquo represents Macbeth’s guilt and psychological collapse.

Overall, Banquo is a threat because he represents:

• a future royal bloodline (prophecy)
• a moral contrast to Macbeth
• a psychological and political danger even after death

---

AO2 (10 marks) – Language, Form & Structure

(How Shakespeare presents Banquo as threatening)

Shakespeare uses language, structure, and dramatic techniques to build Banquo as a growing threat.

The metaphor “Our fears in Banquo stick deep” suggests fear is embedded and cannot be removed, showing Banquo’s lasting impact on Macbeth’s mind.

The phrase “royalty of nature” suggests Banquo has natural authority. This contrasts with Macbeth’s unnatural kingship gained through murder, making Banquo appear more rightful and stable.

Banquo’s language is calm and controlled, such as “my allegiance clear,” showing moral stability. In contrast, Macbeth’s language becomes increasingly emotional and unstable, highlighting Banquo as a steady threat.

Banquo’s warning that “instruments of darkness tell us truths… to betray’s” shows his awareness of deception. This intelligence makes him more dangerous to Macbeth because he understands the witches’ manipulation.

Shakespeare uses Banquo as a foil to Macbeth:

• Banquo = restraint, loyalty, moral awareness
• Macbeth = ambition, violence, paranoia

This contrast increases the sense of threat because Banquo represents what Macbeth should have been.

Dramatic irony also increases tension, as the audience knows Banquo is not actively attacking Macbeth, but Macbeth still fears him. This shows Macbeth’s fear is driven by guilt and insecurity.

Structurally, Banquo’s threat develops across the play:

• Act 1: prophecy introduces future danger
• Act 3: fear leads to Banquo’s murder
• Act 3 Scene 4: ghost scene shows psychological breakdown

Banquo’s ghost may be a hallucination, suggesting the threat is internal as well as external. Fleance’s escape reinforces this fear: “the worm that’s fled… in time will venom breed”, suggesting Banquo’s line continues into the future.

---

AO4 (10 marks) – Context

(Relevant contextual understanding of Banquo as a threat)

Shakespeare presents Banquo positively because he was believed to be an ancestor of King James I, making him a symbol of rightful kingship. This would make Banquo appear noble and legitimate to Jacobean audiences.

In Holinshed’s Chronicles, Banquo is partly involved in Duncan’s murder, but Shakespeare changes this so Banquo is innocent. This makes him a stronger moral contrast to Macbeth.

Jacobean audiences believed in the Divine Right of Kings, meaning kings were chosen by God. Banquo’s “royalty of nature” suggests he aligns with this natural and divine order, while Macbeth’s rule is unnatural and illegitimate. This makes Banquo a political threat.

After the Gunpowder Plot (1605), audiences were highly sensitive to treason and betrayal. Macbeth’s fear of Banquo would reflect real anxieties about hidden threats and political instability.

Belief in witchcraft and prophecy also made Banquo’s future line of kings feel powerful and real to audiences, increasing the sense of danger.

Banquo’s ghost reflects Jacobean beliefs in the supernatural and the idea that guilt and moral wrongdoing return to punish the living.

How does Shakespeare present Macbeth as a tyrant up to Act 4 Scene 3?

(AO1)

• Shakespeare presents Macbeth as a tyrant who becomes increasingly violent, paranoid and ruthless after gaining the throne. Although he begins as a brave and loyal soldier, his ambition leads him to commit regicide and destroy the natural order.
• after hearing the witches’ prophecy, Macbeth quickly becomes focused on power, and his decision to murder Duncan marks the beginning of his transformation into a tyrant. Although he initially hesitates, he is later driven by ambition and Lady Macbeth’s persuasion to commit the murder
• once Macbeth becomes king, he begins to fear threats to his power, especially Banquo, who is predicted to father a line of kings. Macbeth admits: ‘Our fears in Banquo stick deep’, showing his growing paranoia and insecurity as ruler
• Macbeth sees Banquo as a threat not only because of the prophecy but also because Banquo is morally strong and loyal. Banquo remains honest and says he will ‘keep my allegiance clear’, which contrasts with Macbeth’s corruption and increases Macbeth’s fear
• Macbeth’s fear leads him to arrange Banquo’s murder and attempt to kill Fleance, showing that he is willing to use violence repeatedly to secure his position. This shows he is no longer a hesitant murderer but an active tyrant
• at the banquet, Macbeth sees Banquo’s ghost and reacts with extreme panic: ‘Never shake thy gory locks at me!’ This moment shows Macbeth’s mental instability and guilt, and how his tyranny is beginning to destroy his mind
• by Act 4 Scene 3, Macbeth’s tyranny is fully established. He orders the murder of Macduff’s wife and children without hesitation, showing that he now uses cruelty and fear as political tools rather than acting from uncertainty or persuasion
• Macbeth becomes isolated as a ruler, relying on violence and fear to maintain control. His actions show a complete breakdown of morality, as he no longer hesitates to kill innocent people

---

(AO2)

• Language: Macbeth’s fear is shown in the metaphor ‘Our fears in Banquo stick deep’, where the word ‘stick’ suggests his paranoia is fixed and cannot be removed, showing lasting psychological tension
• Language: the phrase ‘royalty of nature’ suggests Banquo has natural kingly qualities, which contrasts with Macbeth’s unnatural rise to power through murder and increases Macbeth’s insecurity
• Language: Banquo’s calm statement ‘keep my allegiance clear’ highlights his moral stability, making Macbeth’s growing corruption more visible to the audience
• Language/Structure: Macbeth’s soliloquies and reactions become increasingly erratic, especially in the banquet scene, showing his psychological breakdown as his tyranny develops
• Language: the violent imagery in ‘Never shake thy gory locks at me!’ shows Macbeth’s fear and guilt, with ‘gory’ emphasising blood and murder, linking his mental collapse to his violent actions
• Structure: Shakespeare shows Macbeth’s progression into tyranny step-by-step: brave hero → murderer of Duncan → paranoid king → murderer of Banquo → cruel tyrant ordering Macduff’s family’s death
• Form: the banquet scene uses dramatic irony, as the audience knows Banquo is dead but Macbeth sees his ghost, showing that Macbeth’s guilt is internal as well as external
• Structure: Banquo’s ghost may be interpreted as a hallucination, suggesting Macbeth’s tyranny is accompanied by psychological destruction and loss of control

---

(AO4)

• Shakespeare presents Macbeth as a tyrant to reflect Jacobean beliefs in the Divine Right of Kings, where killing a king was seen as a serious crime against God and nature
• Macbeth’s murder of Duncan would be seen as regicide, making him a clear tyrant in the eyes of Shakespeare’s audience, who believed kings were chosen by God
• Banquo is presented positively because he was believed to be an ancestor of King James I, making Macbeth’s fear of Banquo more politically significant for Jacobean audiences
• in Holinshed’s Chronicles, Banquo is partly involved in Duncan’s murder, but Shakespeare changes this to make Banquo morally good and a strong contrast to Macbeth’s tyranny
• the play reflects fears after the Gunpowder Plot (1605), when England was highly sensitive to treason, betrayal, and attempts to overthrow authority
• Macbeth’s increasing cruelty, especially the murder of Macduff’s family, would reinforce Jacobean fears about what happens when natural order and loyalty are destroyed
• belief in witchcraft and prophecy also explains Macbeth’s actions, but Shakespeare ultimately presents him as responsible for his own tyranny, driven by ambition rather than fate
• Shakespeare uses Macbeth’s downfall to show that breaking moral and natural order leads to isolation, fear, and destruction of the self and state